This article is by Manjit Rana, EVP of Insurance at Clearspeed
1. How has the ghost broking threat evolved in the past 12 months, particularly through social media and AI-enabled impersonation?
Having investigated ghost broking last year, I would say the biggest change is how cheaply and convincingly criminals can manufacture credibility. Social media provides easy access to potential customers, while AI makes it possible to quickly create professional-looking websites, communications and policy documents. Looking legitimate has become much easier.
What particularly concerns me is that some scams now bypass insurers altogether. The customer receives something that looks like insurance, but no application has reached an insurer and no cover exists. So, insurers with sophisticated fraud detection capabilities can still miss entire transactions which never enter their systems.
That changes where we need to intervene. Prevention must start where people discover and buy insurance, before they hand over their money. We spend a great deal of time discussing how technology can accelerate insurance transactions but need to put the same effort into helping people establish who they can trust at that speed.
2. With 39% of young drivers lacking confidence in spotting fake policies, is the industry doing enough to educate consumers?
There is good work happening. The FCA’s use of influencers and Allianz’s work with a driving instructor are sensible ways to reach young drivers. But that 39% figure shows we haven’t done enough.
Equally, expecting a first-time insurance buyer to become a forensic document examiner is hardly a great customer experience. We should educate people about completing a few straightforward checks: independently verify the firm and its contact details through the FCA, then confirm cover with the named insurer using a trusted contact route.
I would build that guidance into driving lessons, parent communications and the buying journey itself. Someone purchasing their first policy needs useful advice at the moment they are making the decision.
3. How are rising insurance costs and affordability pressures creating opportunities for ghost brokers?
Average premiums may have stabilised in recent periods, but that doesn’t mean insurance feels affordable to a young person who needs a car for work or college.
A ghost broker’s proposition is persuasive: “I can get you what you need at a price you can manage”. The more someone needs that saving to be real, the more willing they may be to believe it.
We risk of leaving consumers in a difficult grey area. We encourage them to shop around because prices vary considerably, but also expect inexperienced buyers to judge when a cheaper price becomes suspicious. That distinction is not always obvious.
Affordability therefore belongs in the prevention discussion. Suitable telematics products, transparent payment options and better access to specialist brokers can help consumers find legitimate alternatives.
Wanting cheaper insurance is perfectly reasonable. We need to understand that motivation as well as the criminals exploiting it.
4. What role should insurers, regulators and social media platforms play in preventing consumers from purchasing fraudulent policies?
Insurers should monitor impersonation of their brands, make policy verification straightforward and share intelligence that others can act on quickly. Regulators should set clear expectations, coordinate enforcement and hold organisations accountable. And social media platforms should verify who is behind an insurance advert, whether they’re authorised, and whether they actually represent the business they claim to.
Platforms benefiting commercially from insurance advertising should also invest properly in preventing impersonation and disrupting repeat offenders. Removing one advert has limited value if the same operation can return almost immediately under another account. We need to address the whole journey, including ordinary posts and messaging channels, because criminals will exploit whichever route receives the least scrutiny.
5. What practical changes would you like to see the industry make in 2027 to tackle ghost broking more effectively?
I would prioritise five practical changes.
First, make verification part of the customer experience. Consumers need a simple, trusted way to confirm their insurer, their policy details and whether cover is active. A convincing PDF should never be the end of the process.
Second, connect intelligence to action. A report about a fraudulent website or account should trigger a coordinated response, with a named owner, a deadline and confirmation that action has been taken.
Third, put education where it can influence a decision: driving lessons, comparison journeys and the point of payment. Explain the scam in language people understand.
Fourth, improve how we support victims. Assess individual circumstances before making decisions about cancellations or fraud markers that could make obtaining legitimate cover even harder.
Finally, measure outcomes: fewer people deceived, faster disruption and quicker access to genuine insurance.
There is a real opportunity for InsurTech here. But before commissioning another solution, decide who will act on its findings, what resources they need and how the operating process will change. Otherwise, we risk generating more alerts without preventing more harm.
For me, innovation earns its place when it makes the customer safer and the response more effective.

Be the first to comment