Some interesting insights in this new Index, here’s the word;
AI benchmarking and intelligence company Evident launches its inaugural Evident AI Index for Asset Management today, revealing BlackRock (1), Vanguard (2), and Fidelity (3) are outpacing their peers in AI maturity.
BlackRock has taken the top position in the Index. It is the only firm to rank in the top three across all four pillars of Evident’s methodology – Talent, Innovation, Leadership and Transparency – a level of consistency comparable with JPMorganChase in the Evident AI Index for Banks.
The Index shows that the top nine firms are pulling away from the pack on AI maturity. Behind the investment and distribution platforms leading the way, hedge funds Bridgewater and Man Group secured 4th and 5th place by building AI capabilities deeper within the investment function itself. Direct platform Charles Schwab (6) follows close behind. Amundi (7), Franklin Templeton (8), and T.Rowe Price (9) fly the flag for the traditional managers, securing positions within the top nine despite most of their peers sitting in the lower half of the Index.
Across the 30 firms included in the Index, Evident identified 320 publicly disclosed AI use cases. While the top nine asset managers make up 30% of the Index, they account for 45% of those use cases. These frontrunners have pulled ahead of their contemporaries in almost every area of AI deployment.
Alexandra Mousavizadeh, Co-Founder and Co-CEO of Evident, commented:
“Our first Evident AI Index for Asset Management shows that the leading firms are poised to accelerate away from the rest of the field, which makes benchmarking their progress more important than ever. As AI becomes part of the investment product itself, firms are forging different paths to tie intelligence to their investment strategies. For now, the evidence shows AI improving the research behind investment decisions – better models, faster analysis and richer signals – but that isn’t yet proof of alpha. Translating AI’s output to superior returns is the next frontier for the industry.”
The Evident AI Index for Asset Management is the most comprehensive independent benchmark of AI maturity across the industry. It covers 30 of the largest asset managers across traditional managers, scaled platforms, private markets firms and hedge funds, drawing exclusively on publicly available data across the four pillars critical to successful AI deployment.
The low-cost firms lead the AI race
Index and direct platforms, firms specialising in low-cost index funds or sell directly to investors via their own platforms, have taken a significant lead in the ranking. They score nearly 60% higher for AI capability than the average firm in the sector. According to Evident, these firms are structurally in the strongest position to capture AI’s value, with low-fee, high volume economics making efficiency a key competitive necessity.
Standardised products and rules-based workflows are more straightforward to automate, and with the fixed cost of building, a successful AI application can be rolled out across thousands of employees, and across millions of client interactions, multiplying its returns.
Each firm has a different strength: BlackRock places in the top three across each pillar. Of note is its agentic research platform, Asimov. It analyses earnings transcripts and research notes, drawing on over 1000 alpha signals to strengthen strategies across ETFs, mutual funds and hedge funds.
Vanguard leads the Index on AI Leadership, with more disclosed AI use cases than any other firm. Its focus on scaling AI is underpinned by an evaluation capability: large-scale simulations test accuracy and expose potential failure modes, so that capabilities are proven before they reach a client. Fidelity leads on Talent and Innovation, accounting for 34% of all AI workers, 43% of AI research output and 78% of AI patents, across the 30 firms.

AI makes its move into investment decisions
While platforms lead on breadth of AI maturity, the hedge funds stand out for depth of deployment, pulling ahead in implementing AI within the investment function itself. Bridgewater’s $4.5 billion AIA Macro Fund positions AI at the centre of the investment process, using machine learning to generate, test, and evaluate investment ideas. Man Group is automating the upstream research process, using AI agents to formulate and test trading hypotheses.
The first step in the AI journey for asset managers is often focused on making investment teams more productive. The Index leaders take this one step further, using AI to improve investment decisions and, if the model allows, commit client capital directly. The top nine account for 48% of all investment use cases disclosed.
Connecting AI back to the bottom line
The Index finds that while individual AI use cases are starting to show their outcomes, firm-wide returns remain scarce. Only three asset managers (AllianceBernstein, Carlyle Group, and Vanguard) have disclosed their projected or realised returns across AI activities, with Carlyle ($470M) and Vanguard ($450M) reporting specific realised figures. This compares with 26% of banks in The Evident AI Index for Banks.
Distribution offers the most tangible line of sight between AI and commercial impact. It has the highest share of use cases with reported outcomes of any business area (62%). For example, Franklin Templeton reported an 11% uplift in sales and a 25% increase in client contacts in the regions its AI-powered Intelligence Hub was rolled out.
Jack McKie, Director, Asset Management at Evident, commented:
“For asset managers, value is easiest to demonstrate where the AI is furthest from the investment decision, and it’s hardest to prove where it matters most. As AI moves deeper into investment processes, clients, investors and regulators alike will expect transparent evidence of what it is actually being delivered.
“There is no single blueprint for AI leadership in asset management. Direct platforms, hedge funds, traditional managers, and private markets firms are taking different approaches across their varied investment strategies to try and gain advantage. As access to intelligent models becomes universal, differentiation comes by investing in what makes a firm unique – proprietary data, intellectual property, and domain expertise.”

Be the first to comment