Fighting Fraud Without Failing Vulnerable Customers

Sarah Durkin, Director of Investigations at Woodgate & Clark discusses the delicate balance of tackling insurance fraud while supporting vulnerable customers;

This International Fraud Awareness Week comes as cost-of-living pressures show little sign of easing. While financial strain can provide a motive for fraud, increasingly sophisticated AI techniques and the faceless nature of claims submissions make it easier for fraudsters to try their luck.

At the same time, awareness and diagnosis of neurodivergence are growing, and approximately 15% of the U.K. population is neurodivergent with differences such as autism, ADHD, dyslexia, dyspraxia, dyscalculia and Tourette’s syndrome. Meanwhile, around half of UK financial services customers are now considered vulnerable.

That translates to potentially around one in seven claims coming from a neurodivergent individual and one in two claims from a customer with characteristics of vulnerability.

For those working in claims, escalating fraud combined with growing numbers of customers who are neurodivergent or vulnerable presents unique challenges. Namely, how to identify vulnerability or neurodiversity and how to offer the right care, while remaining vigilant to the possibility of fraud.

The changing face of claims fraud

£1.34bn worth of fraudulent claims were detected last year and exaggerated losses were the most common type of fraud, according to the Association of British Insurers (ABI)iv. This reflects our experience at Woodgate & Clark. There has been a marked increase in the number of exaggerated claims where policyholders attempt to maximise the opportunity to increase the value of what’s been stolen or damaged. We have also seen a rise in claims where the policy was taken out after the damage or loss had already occurred.

Recognising vulnerability

Against this backdrop, around 60% of the claims referred to our counter fraud team at Woodgate & Clark involve customers showing signs of vulnerability. That doesn’t mean those customers are committing fraud. It shows how often vulnerability and fraud indicators overlap, and why a referral should never be treated as a conclusion.

One of the biggest challenges faced is that many vulnerable customers do not recognise their own vulnerability. Even if they are aware they are neurodivergent, not every customer will disclose it at the outset. Maybe they don’t feel it is relevant, or don’t feel comfortable sharing personal information with an insurer. This is why more insurers are now training claims teams to recognise signs of vulnerability. Typical signs may be confusion, difficulty processing information, memory lapses, or inconsistent explanations that do not appear intentional.

When vulnerability can resemble fraud

A further challenge is that behaviours associated with vulnerability can sometimes resemble fraud red flags. For example, a claimant might give inconsistent answers, struggle with the sequence of events or find it difficult to provide additional documentation. These behaviours may be referred to to a fraud team for further investigation, but they could reflect difficulties processing information linked to neurodivergence.

Adapting support without lowering standards

So, it is important for claims professionals to consider whether the way they are asking for information is affecting its reliability. Practical adjustments can be made, without lowering evidential standards.

For example, where vulnerability is identified or suspected, claims teams can use plain English, break information into manageable sections and ask claimants how they would prefer to receive communications. They can also allow more time for responses and, with the claimant’s consent, involve a trusted family member to provide support.

The FCA expects businesses to adapt their communications and customer support to individual needsv and it is really encouraging that the conversation surrounding fair treatment of vulnerable and neurodiverse customers is increasing.

However, as fraudsters target much bigger payouts, claims teams have a huge responsibility. They must remain alert to suspicious evidence but at the same time recognise that there could be an underlying reason for a customer’s behaviour that may not be linked to fraud.

Improving training and practical guidance used by claims teams can help us all achieve the right balance between supporting vulnerable customers and fighting fraud. Insurers will be able to reach defensible decisions, based on thorough evidence, while every claimant, neurodiverse, neurotypical, vulnerable or not, is treated with empathy and respect.

About alastair walker 21416 Articles
20 years experience as a journalist and magazine editor. I'm your contact for press releases, events, news and commercial opportunities at Insurance-Edge.Net

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.