Fire Safety Gaps That Keep Showing Up in Claims Data

Claims handlers who deal with commercial property fires will recognise the same story repeating itself. The risk assessment is years out of date, fire doors haven’t been tested since they went in, escape routes are partially blocked, and the person listed as “responsible” for fire safety sometimes couldn’t even point you towards the nearest extinguisher.

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) figures for the year ending March 2026 put hard numbers to the problem. Of 50,195 fire safety audits carried out in England, 20,286 came back unsatisfactory, and inadequate fire risk assessments alone accounted for 9,271 recorded breaches, up 9.3% on the year before.

These failings aren’t a surprise to most adjusters, but the real issue is that they keep appearing in post-fire reviews and then dragging out the adjustment stage. Here’s where the compliance data and the claims data actually line up.

The Training Gap That Follows the Fire

Fire safety law in England says every commercial premises needs a “responsible person” who takes ownership of fire risk. In practice, the title usually goes to whoever was around when the duty needed assigning, often a site manager or business owner who ticked a box during onboarding but never went through any structured fire safety education. When a fire occurs and the adjuster asks to see training records, they’re either paper-thin or missing entirely.

The audit data backs that up. Breaches of Article 21 of the Fire Safety Order, which covers training, were recorded 4,445 times in 2025/26, up 35% on six years ago. Article 19, covering the information employers must give employees, was breached 3,954 times, up 89% over the same period. Those are the two provisions most likely to leave an adjuster with nothing to read after a fire.

This gap turns up again and again in post-incident reviews. When the records are in order, they’ll usually show the responsible person has worked through a NEBOSH fire safety course or an equivalent that covers risk assessment methodology, fire prevention, protection measures and emergency planning. It’s no surprise that premises where the responsible person holds a recognised qualification tend to have better-maintained equipment, more current risk assessments and clearer evacuation procedures.

When that baseline competence isn’t there, it tends to be the common thread behind multiple compliance failures on a single site. It also affects the quality of records available after a fire, because without training logs, drill records, maintenance check sheets and equipment certificates, the claims process slows down considerably. And training is only one line in the audit data. The wider figures show the same upward pattern across nearly every requirement inspectors check.

What the MHCLG Audit Numbers Tell Insurers

Of the 50,195 fire safety audits carried out in 2025/26, 60% had a satisfactory outcome, barely moved from 59% the year before. The breach numbers tell a different story. Emergency routes and exits topped the list at 11,286, up 9.3%, followed by maintenance failures at 9,727, up 12%, and, as mentioned above, inadequate fire risk assessments at 9,271, also up 9.3%. Nine of the ten most frequently cited articles recorded more breaches than the previous year. Adjusters will find all of those familiar, because they’re the exact issues that tend to cause headaches on site after a fire.

Most commercial premises get a risk assessment when they first open or switch insurers, and then the document gets filed away. The building might change use, add a mezzanine, or move to 24-hour operations, but the assessment stays frozen in time. By the time a fire happens, there’s a mismatch between what was assessed and what actually exists, and that mismatch causes real complications for the claim. The insured’s fire safety arrangements won’t match what was disclosed at placement, which gives the insurer grounds to push back.

A Shrinking Data Pool for Fire Risk Pricing

The Chartered Institute of Loss Adjusters flagged a connected problem in mid-2026 when it drew attention to declining submissions to the RISCAuthority Large Loss Database, which is the industry’s central source of UK fire and flood claims data. Loss adjusters historically logged at least 500 large loss cases per year, but submissions dropped off in 2023 and 2024 even though losses kept happening.

For underwriters and brokers, that drop creates a pricing headache. If the data feeding into fire risk models gets less complete over time, premiums won’t accurately reflect recent loss severity. CILA has since worked with RISCAuthority to relaunch a simplified version of the database in July 2026, but the gap in recent data hasn’t been backfilled. The industry is essentially trying to price fire risk during a period of rising compliance failure while working with an incomplete picture of what those failures are actually costing.

The rebuilt version strips the submission down from over 400 data points to around 40, with a deliberate focus on emerging causes including lithium-ion battery fires and sustainable construction materials. For commercial property, adjusters are asked to log any claim above £100,000 or involving a fatality. That narrower scope should lift submission rates, but it also means the industry’s picture of newer fire causes starts from close to nothing.

When Non-Disclosure Meets the Adjustment Stage

The Insurance Act 2015 introduced the duty of fair presentation, which requires commercial policyholders to disclose all material circumstances before a policy is placed or renewed. Fire safety arrangements fall squarely within scope, including the status of risk assessments, maintenance records, alarm system logs and the competence of the responsible person. When the adjustment process turns up gaps that should have been disclosed, the insurer’s remedies under the Act become a live issue.

A claim can be challenged even without intentional concealment. A business that genuinely didn’t know its fire risk assessment was outdated can still face problems, because the duty extends to information the insured “ought to know” through reasonable enquiry. Fire doors propped open with wedges, extinguishers past their service dates, blocked escape routes and alarm panels showing long-standing faults are all material circumstances that an insured should reasonably have been aware of before the loss occurred.

What the Claims Pattern Means for the Market

Regulatory non-compliance and claims disputes will keep colliding until the market responds more deliberately. MHCLG figures show audit outcomes holding roughly flat while recorded breaches and enforcement keep climbing, with formal notifications up 11% and prohibition notices up 27% in a single year. Set against six years ago, unsatisfactory audits are up 23% and maintenance breaches up 52%. The CILA data gap means the industry can’t reliably measure what any of that is costing at scale.

Brokers will need to think carefully about their duty of care at placement by asking clients about the status of their fire risk assessment, the training held by their responsible person, recent drill records and the maintenance regime for fire safety equipment, all of which can help prevent a fair presentation dispute down the line.

Adjusters and underwriters should take a harder look at fire safety documentation at every stage, from pre-risk survey through to first notification of loss. The compliance failures that government audits keep identifying are the same ones that complicate claims, delay settlements, generate coverage disputes and push up legal costs. Until fire safety management in commercial premises actually improves, the same gaps will keep turning up on every site visit, and the claims that follow will keep running into the same arguments about what was disclosed and what wasn’t.

About alastair walker 21460 Articles
20 years experience as a journalist and magazine editor. I'm your contact for press releases, events, news and commercial opportunities at Insurance-Edge.Net

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.